Showing posts with label research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label research. Show all posts

Thursday, 24 April 2014

#becomingeducational W26: Crisis what crisis?

This week Quaco led the lecture session with a cracking account of the real purpose of research – making connections with your Research Project – and especially with the Research Report that everybody had to write to finish off this part of the analytical process. This Report and this process is not a pointless assessment hoop to jump through!

The point of research is to investigate an aspect of our world and then to tell people about what we did, why we did it – what we discovered – what it might mean – and what practical applications it has in the world.



There’s no point in keeping research to yourself!
In Education particularly it helps us all if research relates to our real experiences – it all makes much more sense when we know what is happening and why – if we can see a practical purpose to the work. And that is the point of this Research Project. You were asked to investigate an issue or an aspect of teaching and learning that you found interesting. You are supposed to use your interest to help you do the work. You are supposed to use that interest to help you make sense of your findings: you should know WHY you were investigating what you did – so you should know WHAT you want to tell the world about what you have discovered.

So – one last time: The Report
The Report part of this Project is where you report your findings – you discuss what the raw data might mean – you draw conclusions as to their relevance to *this* context (for you were analysing an aspect of HE study) – and where applicable you make Recommendation for Practice, that is, suggestions for how to improve the learning for University students, based on your analysis of your research data:
Findings
Discussion
Conclusions
Recommendations for Practice
Bibliography

Try to stop worrying about this as ACADEMIC WRITING – try to stop worrying about this as an ASSESSMENT – try to think about it as having something to SAY to REAL PEOPLE.

Of your RESEARCH PROPOSAL that would have been asking:
So what are you going to investigate? - INTRODUCTION
Why are you interested in that topic? – BACKGROUND/CONTEXT
What have other academics already discovered about that topic? – LITERATURE REVIEW
How will you carry out your own research? - METHOD
Why have you chosen to carry out the research in that way? - METHOD

Of your RESEARCH REPORT they will be asking:
So what happened when you conducted your research? What are the key highlights? – FINDINGS
What do your findings mean? – DISCUSSION
What overall conclusions do you draw about University teaching/learning? – CONCLUSION
What should we do differently because of what you have found out? – RECOMMENDATIONS

Okay – so it is all in just 1000 words! So no room for a lot of description – but quite a lot of *concise* analysis and discussion required.

AND – if you are still struggling with this – talk to other people in the class – what is baffling when we are alone with our worries becomes sensible and do-able when we work with other people!!

BUT if you do not want to talk to anyone – read some educational research and see how other people write it up. As we have mentioned before – the free online journal: Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education covers exactly the sort of research that you are doing – and will offer excellent models for how you should write up your work: http://www.aldinhe.ac.uk/ojs/index.php?journal=jldhe

Conference session
This week in the Workshop time, students had the option of continuing to work on their assignments or attending a session where we shared our Conference  presentation. This year we presented at the Association for Learning Development in Higher Education Conference upon the topic of blogging your learning – with a particular focus on the blogging that we have asked you to do here in the Becoming module.

The workshop was a chance for us to show you what a formal academic conference presentation might look like – and to show you the sort of research that we engage in as educationalists ourselves. If you missed the Workshop – or would like to find out a bit more about the conference itself – please go to our Least Refuge blog: http://lastrefugelmu.blogspot.co.uk/2014/04/aldinhe-conference-2014-learning.html. It would be great if you popped in a Comment or some feedback!


Tuesday, 26 June 2012

Re-posting thesis Whisperer: Ethics part one!

Loved this post on ETHICS so much that I had to share it - at least with myself... So here is another post from The Thesis Whisperer
" (Human) ethics applications with a minimum of pain (part one)
by Judy Redman

This post is by Judy Redman who is a Uniting Church minister and, as part of her role as a university chaplain, has been minister of religion on the human research ethics committees of three different Australian universities. She has qualifications in Agricultural Science and Human Nutrition as well as Theology and is currently working on a PhD. Her university-related work experience has also involved being a research assistant and academic editing. In this post Judy lends you her vast experience to help you with your ethics application - thanks Judy!

The post:
If you wander into a university tea-room and say you are writing an ethics application, you are sure to attract sympathetic looks and a range of horror stories. Everyone seems to know of someone who took 27 tries and two years to get their application through, and a number of researchers are firmly convinced that the sole reason for the ethics application process is to impede their research.

I've been a member of human research ethics committees for three different universities for some 15 years and this has not been my experience. I must have been involved in reviewing close to 2,000 applications and I don’t remember a committee ever having refused an application outright, although two or three researchers have decided to withdraw their applications.

I’ve been told by a significant number of experienced researchers that completing the ethics application form helps them to clarify exactly what it is that they hope to find out. I want to help you have a good experience too. There is quite a lot to ethics applications, so this post will look at the general process and the next one will look specifically at the information you provide for participants, since this is what causes most people (including ethics committee members) the most angst.

There is some Australian-specific information here, but the basic principles will apply fairly universally.

Why do I need to do an ethics application?
We have responsibilities towards our research participants. People are giving up their time (and sometimes also putting themselves at risk) to enable you to do your research. We need to ensure they can give free and informed consent to their participation and ensure their safety, particularly vunerable groups.

We must provide fair access to the benefits of research to all participants. In the past researchers have denied participants access to a life-saving procedure or product on the grounds that s/he needs to have a control group (see for example the Tuskagee Syphilis Study and the New Zealand National Women’s Hospital experiment).

Finally, there are regulatory issues. if you are associated with an Australian univerity, funding groups like the ARC and NH&MRC can pull all their research grant funding from a university if one just person is found to be in breach of the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research.

Contrary to popular belief, looking at your research design & methodology is part of the committee’s role. It's unethical to conduct research which cannot achieve what it says it aims to do. To put this another way: if you tell your participants that their participation in the research will help you to determine X, but the design of your research will not, in fact, allow you to determine X, you are recruiting participants under false pretences (aka lying to them).

Stress free applications!
I recommend all research students read sections 1 & 2 of the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research and any other parts that are relevant to your particular research. The statement explains what can and can’t be done - and why; it will help you to understand the reasoning behind the questions on the application forms.

It's important to follow the processes which are in place in your university so you don't slow the process down. Download the current version of the application form and the guidelines that go with them from your university website and read them carefully.

DO NOT (yes, I know I am shouting) accept the copy that your supervisor or friend kindly emails to you. It could be out of date and you may fail to provide critical information as a result.

When you start to fill out the form, read the questions carefully and answer them fully and write the answers in language that people who are not specialists in your field can understand. DO NOT just attach your research proposal and expect the ethics committee members to refer to it for answers. They may have 15 or 20 applications to read and at best they will become very, very grumpy about your application and at worst will send it back for you to do again.

If you are confused, ask the secretary of your ethics committee or a committee member for help. They would much rather that you ask and get it right! This can help you avoid...

Common Problems
Not enough detail about recruitment: “students” is not an acceptable answer to the request to “describe how you plan to recruit participants.” We need to know which students, how you plan to identify them, how you plan to approach them, and whether there is a conflict of interest - particularly if they are in a dependent relationship with you (ie are they students that you teach, whose work you mark or over whom you have some other kind of power).

Erroneous assumptions: Just because you have access to particular databases in your work, does not mean that you can simply use them to access potential participants for your research. Doing this without permission puts you in breach of most privacy legislation.

Incomplete questions: If the form asks you to respond Yes or No, it is quite possible that there may be a section which requires you to provide justification of your answer. Check this, or it's likely you will get your application back again.

Not enough detail: If you are doing research overseas, just telling us how much money (whether in the local currency or in AUD) you are planning to pay participants is not enough. Are you paying them enough to buy a cup of coffee - or a new home? We need to know whether you are offering too much inducement to engage in risky behaviour.

Justification not provided for potentially sensitive data collection methods: If you need to deceive participants (eg by not tell them that you are observing them or not telling them exactly what you’re looking for) you will need a good reason.

Not enough reason given for keeping identifiable data: You will need to explain why you need that information, especially if it is potentially sensitive information such as sexual orientation, ethnicity, religious affiliation, age etc. “Because the study I am trying to replicate collected it” is not good enough.

Not understanding the significance of anonymity vs confidentiality: Anonymous data (ie data that is collected without any identifying information attached to it) is reasonably problem free. You can ask all sorts of controversial or sensitive things as long as you cannot link responses to the person who made them. If you collect sensitive data and you know who gave it to you, you need to think about how to maintain confidentiality.

If you are de-identifying your data you need to be clear about who will be able to put the identifiers back. Note also that removing names doesn’t necessarily de-identify data for high profile people. Most organisations only have one CEO and Australia has only ever had one female prime minister. In this kind of situation, you ask for permission to publish the names of the interviewees and provide them with a copy of the transcript of their interview for approval.


I hope this post helps you start to sort through your ethical issues - does anyone have any questions or problems? Ask us in the comments.

Related post: The researcher's hunch "
ENDS